Meet the Team

Ted Coalter


Learn More  

Debbie Coalter


Laura Coalter Parker


Michael Siebert


Laura Matlock-Hill


Melissa Ashley


Hailey Mouser


Patrick Martin


Eric Craiglow


Andrew Thompson


Jane Lohmann

Customer Service

Want to join the team?

Call us at

(573) 339-1222

Our Commitment

To combat the constantly rising costs of Insurance, Coalter Insurance Group is committed to finding the best insurance package for you or your business. Our highly trained, professional staff will research and compare each insurance carrier to ensure you choose a plan that will provide you the most value for every premium dollar you invest.

Coalter Insurance Group feels your insurance burden. From administration needs to claims payment situations, we work diligently to meet the needs of our clients by eliminating the “red tape” we see daily in the industry.

Rising costs associated with claims and double digit insurance inflation are two reasons for rising insurance premiums. Coalter Insurance group is here to help you through the claims process. We also help you understand the best ways to receive the treatment you deserve while controlling out-of-pocket expenses. When insurance coverage is used as intended, annual premium increases are minimized.

Your life is full of precious people and possessions, and all of them need to be protected against the uncertainties of life. Coalter Insurance Group cares about you and your needs, and we look forward to advising you on the strategic plans that will work for you, your business, and those you love.

Our History

Our journey started when our founder, Ted R. Coalter, moved to Cape Girardeau to attend college at SEMO in 1973. Ted began selling insurance as a means to pay for college tuition and then discovered his true passion and entrepreneurship. That passion and drive led Ted to open his own brokerage in 1985. Over 30 years our agency has grown and evolved with the ever-changing insurance world.

aetna travelers anthem mutual of omaha progressive United healthcare safeco  liberty mutual the hartford CFM Insurance State Auto Transamerica Ohio National MetLife Allstate United Home

Request A Quote